5. Joel Chatfield & Ruth Stoddard

by Catherine Sevenau on May 11, 2011

Joel Chatfield

  • 2nd child of Elnathan Chatfield & Hannah Northrup
  • Born: Feb 21, 1757, Milford, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Jun 14, 1836 (age 79), Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Religion: Episcopalian
  • Occupation: Farmer, miller
  • Military: War of 1812
  • Married: Nov 13, 1785, Ruth Stoddard, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Seven children: ISAAC CHATFIELD, Leman/Lyman Chatfield, Almira Chatfield, Oliver Stoddard Chatfield, Charlotte Chatfield, Thirza Chatfield, Joel Raymond Chatfield

Ruth Stoddard

  • Daughter of Gideon Stoddard & Prudence Terrill
  • Born: May 20, 1760, Woodbury, Litchfield County, Connecticut
  • Died: Nov 21, 1831 (age 70), Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Married: Nov 13, 1785, Joel Chatfield, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Seven children: ISAAC CHATFIELD, Leman/Lyman Chatfield, Almira Chatfield, Oliver Stoddard Chatfield, Charlotte Chatfield, Thirza Chatfield, Joel Raymond Chatfield

1. ISAAC CHATFIELD

  • Born: Jan 15, 1787, Derby (near Seymour), New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Aug 1, 1861 (age 73), North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
  • Buried: Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
  • Married: 1806, LUCY TOMLINSON, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Eleven children: Lucius Napoleon Chatfield, Lucy Almira Chatfield, Albert Alonzo Chatfield, LEVI TOMLINSON CHATFIELD, Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, Ruth Ann Chatfield, Charles Henry Chatfield(#1), Charlotte Ann Chatfield, Marie Antoinette Chatfield, Gilbert Lafayette Chatfield, Georgianna A. Chatfield

2. Leman/Lyman Chatfield

  • Born Feb 18, 1789, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Nov 5, 1873 (age 84), Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut (on father’s homestead)
  • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Married (1): Oct 19, 1817, Mary H. Sweetland
  • One child: Henry Chatfield
  • Married (2): Jul 8, 1849, Mrs. Sarah (Sellock) Dibble, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut

3. Almira Chatfield

  • Born: Jun 23, 1791, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Dec 12, 1873 (age 82), Humphreysville in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Married: Mar 25, 1824, John Todd Wheeler, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • One child: Charlotte Wheeler (adopted)

4. Oliver Stoddard Chatfield

  • Born: Nov 19, 1793, Woodbridge, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Mar 16, 1877 (age 83), Woodbridge, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Buried: Northwest Cemetery in Woodbridge, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Military: Captain of military company
  • Occupation: Shipping trade, farmer, ran his father’s sawmill in New Haven
  • Affiliation: Royal Arch Mason, Morning Star Lodge, F. & A.M.
  • Married: Feb 2, 1826, Abigail Tuttle, Woodbridge, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Eight children: Mary Jane Chatfield, George Wooster Chatfield, Martha Ann Chatfield, Howard Guy Chatfield, Henry Wheeler Chatfield, John J. Chatfield, Ruth Abigail Chatfield, Charles Converse Chatfield

5. Charlotte Chatfield

  • Born: Dec 15, 1795, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Oct 27, 1828 (age 33), prob New Haven, Connecticut
  • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Married: Mar 1, 1815, John Clark Wheeler, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Six children: Henry Wakeman Wheeler, Frances A. Wheeler, Howard Wheeler, John T. Wheeler, Sarah Wheeler, Charlotte Wheeler

6. Thirza Chatfield

  • Born: Feb 8, 1798, Milford, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Dec 23, 1872 (age 74), New Haven, Connecticut
  • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Never married

7. Joel Raymond Chatfield

    • Born: Feb 16, 1804, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: Feb 4, 1894 (age 90), Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Buried: Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Occupation: Teacher
    • Married (1): May 7, 1826, Lucinda Hitchcock, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Two children: Clark Chatfield, Sarah Lucinda Chatfield
    • Married (2): Jun 25, 1837, Mary (Tomlinson) Wooster, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Eight children: John Chatfield, Edwin Chatfield, Ransom Chatfield, Hiram Chatfield, Mary Tomlinson Chatfield, Joel Chatfield, Charlotte Frances Chatfield, Hattie Minerva Chatfield

Joel Chatfield & Ruth Stoddard

History, Newspaper Articles, Letters, etc.:
Book Excerpt Census Record Letter, Family Note, Diary
Military Record Newspaper Voter Record, Land Record, City Directory

Note: The spelling and punctuation in the following census records, certificates, newspaper articles, documents and letters have been copied as written (though periods were added in some letters to have them make sense). However, you won’t remember this and will send me notes wanting to correct them.

Pictured below are some of this Chatfield line buried in the Trinity Cemetery in Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut. There are also numerous Stoddard headstones along with Leman Chatfield’s in the rear row.

Photo courtesy of Steven Smith, Oxford, New Haven CT (Find A Grave)

From left to right in front row: Mary Chatfield (wife of Leman), (Leman Chatfield in rear row), Joel Chatfield, Lucinda Chatfield (wife of Joel) and Thirza Chatfield

The epitaph on Thirza’s headstone (at far right): “Whereon I was blind, now I see.”

296 Seymour Road, Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
The last historic property on the south side of Seymour Road before the border within the Town of Seymour, this house faces generally north. Bladen’s Brook runs along the other side of the road.296 Seymour Road is a late example of a center-chimney Colonial with a saltbox form. The rear lean to is not original construction but may have been added during the building’s early history. Hewn overhangs found on the side elevations are elaborated with a dentil course, as are the rakes of the eaves, a trim applied during the renovation of the building in, the 1940s. The central doorway in the five-bay facade has a six-panel door, framed by six-paned sidelights and surmounted by a blind fan with an Islamic arch, the latter also dating from the 1940s. There are 6-over-six sash in the gable peaks and generally 12-over-12 in the rest of the windows. 

Historically important for its association with the Chatfield family. this house was built about 1815 on land Joel Chatfield (1756-1836) had received from his mother, Hannah Chatfield, in 1789 (part of his father Elnathan’s estate). Elnathan Chatfield (1733-c. 1785) was a descendant of the George Chatfield who came to Guilford in 1639 with the Reverend Henry Whitfield. The title search reveals that both Joel Chatfield and his eldest son, Isaac, removed to Derby and disposed of all their holdings on this side of the border. Among them was this lot that Isaac had received from his father in 1812. When he sold it in 1817 to his brother, Oliver Stoddard Chatfield (1793-1877), the deed contained the first mention of a dwelling.

Like many wealthy farmers’ sons in this period, Oliver Stoddard had opted for an academic career. After graduating from Yale, he was the publisher of the New England Journal of Education in Boston. Returning to Woodbridge to take up the rural life, he married Abigail Tuttle, had seven children, and became quite wealthy running the family lumber mill on Bladen’s Brook. It supplied timber for the old statehouse, buildings at Yale, and the First Methodist Church, all in New Haven. Although a member of the Episcopal church in Seymour for 67 years, Oliver lived out his life on his Woodbridge farm, which the 1870 census indicates he ran with the help of his wife, several laborers and servants. Only Ruth (30), his youngest child, was still at home.

Source: Wikipedia, Amity & Woodbridge Historical Society, Inc.;http://massarofarm.org/awhs/tiki-index.php

Joel Chatfield (father)
Joel Chatfield, Sr. built a house a few hundred feet from his father’s house, on the south bank of the stream, and the house was after owned and occupied by his son Leman. He was one of the First Society’s Committee of the Episcopal Church (now Trinity Church) in 1797 in Milford, Connecticut. There was in his time a gristmill a few rods northeast of the house, with two run of stone. One pair were French Burr stones for which he sent to France, nothing of the kind having been found in this country at that time. He ground wheat extensively, large quantities of it being grown in this vicinity. For years he supplied Yale College with all the wheat flour used there.
Source: Cheryl (Chatfield) Thompson

Leman/Lyman Chatfield (2nd child of Joel Chatfield & Ruth Stoddard)
Lyman was a selectman of the town of Derby, New Haven, Connecticut in 1838 and 1840, and in 1841 he represented the town of Derby in the legislature. He was one of the most active in the movement for the incorporation of Seymour, New Haven, CT in 1850, his name was the first on the petition presented to the legislature, and in the act of incorporation he is named as the moderator of the first town meeting. At this meeting he was elected first selectman and was re-elected to that office for several years. In 1852 he was elected justice of the peace and in 1854 re-elected for two years. He is mentioned in the History of King Hiram Lodge as one of its members and as one who had the courage to affix his name to the memorable Masonic declaration of principles in 1832. 
He died at the age of 84 years.
Source: Cheryl (Chatfield) Thompson

SEYMOUR, PAST & PRESENT
History of Seymour, Chapter II (excerpts)Seymour was incorporated as a town by the May, 1850, session of the general assembly, upon the petition of Leman Chatfield and others. The first town election was held in the basement of the Methodist church June 24, 1850, and the following were elected: Selectmen, Leman Chatfield, David L. Holbrook, Thos. Cochran; Town Clerk, Charles B. Wooster; Town Treasurer, Sylvester Smith. On the 31st of March, 1851, Bennett Wooster was elected the first representative of the town of Seymour to the general assembly. Its name was given out of compliment to Hon. T.H. Seymour, then the Governor of the State.

Bladens Brook was one of these favored localities, due in part to the water power. The Beach paper mill marks the location of one of the first fulling mills in the region. In 1799 Titus Beach bought the land and built a fulling mill. Johnson, French, and Chatfield were among the first to settle along Bladens Brook and north on Skokorat. The homestead of the Chatfields was on the south side of this brook, more than a mile eastward from the Falls, and one-fourth of a mile from the Milford, or Woodbridge line. The land was purchased from the proprietors of the town of Derby March 24, 1762, by Elnathan Chatfield and Hannah his wife. He built a saw mill and a corn mill very soon after the purchase. From Elnathan it passed to his oldest son, Joel Chatfield, 1778, who built a much larger mill on the west side, two stories in height, the first mill being only one story and a half. There was a bridge from the flume leading to the second floor of the first mill, and two steps enabling one to pass to the second floor of the new mill. In the new mill there was machinery for grinding wheat and rye for flour. The stones were from France, and were among the earliest imported into this country. In 1782 he built the double house now standing and married Ruth Stoddard of Woodbury, Conn., the next year. Among their seven children were Leman who lived on the old homestead, and Joel R. who lived on the Skokorat road to be mentioned later, and lived to be 90 years of age.

The old Chatfield house was large and roomy, with a two story ell on the northeast corner, facing the south and highway. Its appearance is very old looking, especially when shaded by a large spruce tree. Mrs. Chatfield was a progressive woman, who wanted something better than pewter or heavy yellow dishes, so she made an engagement with a sea-captain to get her a set of genuine china-ware direct from China, paying for the same in advance with the product of the farm. After many months the coveted crockery came, to her satisfaction. Though doing good service for many years there are now but two or three pieces remaining, being in the possession of Miss Mary Chatfield.

The original tract of land, or the first purchase made by Elnathan Chatfield, contained four and one half acres, located between the brook and highway, beginning one eighth of a mile from the Milford or Woodbridge line. The old mill stood north of the house, but nothing now remains except the stone foundation and the embankments of the canals.

Source: Seymour, Past and Present, by Rev. Hollis A. Campbell, William C. Sharpe, Frank G. Bassett; W.C. Sharpe Publisher, 1902. Entered according to Act of Congress in the year 1902

Oliver Chatfield (4th child of Joel Chatfield & Ruth Stoddard)
Oliver and Abigail lived in a house which stands on the south side of the road from Seymour to New Haven and is crossed by the boundary line between Seymour and Woodbridge.Oliver thought, when young, he would like to follow the sea, but after one voyage to the West Indies he was content to remain at home. He was Captain of a military company in Bethany. He ran his Father’s mill, furnishing timber for the older Yale College Buildings, for the first M.E. Church that used to stand on the corner of the New Haven Green, and for other prominent buildings of the period.

He was a member of the Morning Star Lodge, F. & A.M. of Seymour, New Haven, CT and a Royal Arch Mason. At his death he was one of the oldest Masons in CT.

He purchased on Apr 6, 1826, from Stiles Johnson and others, several tracts of land bordering on land of Joel Chatfield and others, and on Apr 5, 1832, he purchased from Agur and Polly Tomlinson a smaller tract of land on the north side of the highway “about one mile eastwardly of Humphreysville,” the land being bounded westerly, northerly and easterly on land of said O.S. Chatfield. A memorandum on the deed designates the dwelling house as the “Dick House”. He owned five farms and worked them for a number of years.

He was a hospitable and genial host, a lover of his family and always glad to have his children and his grandchildren about him. His Father was one of the wealthy men of his time. He had a set of china made for his Wife with the initials of her name, R.C. on each piece, and some of the pieces are still preserved by the descendants.

Source: The Chatfield Family, by William C. Sharpe, 1896, Seymour, New Haven, CT.

 

Connecticut Journal

GenealogyBank.com is the source for the above Connecticut Journal banner and the following early American newspaper articles:

Jan 12, 1780: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 2):
TAKEN up by the Subscriber the 28th of October a SORREL MARE COLT, one Year old past, has a Star in her Forehead. The owner may have her by proving Property, paying Charges, and applying to JOEL CHATFIELD, of Bethany.
Note: Joel Chatfield is age 22

Jun 5, 1783: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 3):

Non-Residents, take care!

FOR Notice is hereby given by us the Subscribers, that the Lands belonging to Non-Resident Proprietors, that lies within Town of Derby, will be sold at public auction, at the Dwelling-House of Mr. Oliver Curtics Inn-holder in said Derby, on the 21st Day of July next, at two of the Clock Afternoon, to pay the County Taxes due on said Lands on the List 1780, and 1781; the Owners of the Lands are …, Daniel Chatfield, …, Joel Chatfield, …, Isaac Tomlinson, …, Samuel Chatfield, …
Thomas Yale}

David Hitchcock} Collectors.

Derby, June 2, 1783.

Jan 28, 1784: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):
TAKEN up by the Subscriber, living in Milford, in the Parish of Bethany, on the 30th of December, 1783, a dark brown MARE COLT, coming two Years old, with four white Feet, and no Brand. The owner is desired to take him away and pay charges.JOEL CHATFIELD.

Bethany, (in Milford) January 10, 1784.

Mar 2, 1785: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 3):
NOTICE is herby given, to the resident and non-resident Proprietors of the Town of Derby, that so much of their Lands will be Sold at Public Auction, as to pay their State Taxes on this Lists 1782, and 1783, together with the Costs, at the Sign-Post in Derby, on Monday, the 25th Day of April next, at one o’Clock after noon, viz… Eli Chatfield, …, Joel Chatfield, …, Levi Chatfield, …, Samuel Chatfield, …, —and the other Inhabitants of said Town, who have not settled their Taxes, may expect Cost, if their Taxes are not settled by the first of April, by their humble Servant, DAVID TOMLINSON, Collector of State Taxes

Jul 20, 1785: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):
Broke into the Enclosure of the Subscriber, on the third of June, a red pied Milch HEIFER, two years old, and marked with a Crop off the right Ear, and a Half-penny under the fame, and a half Tennant under the Left.The owner is desired to take him away and pay charges.

JOEL CHATFIELD.

Bethany, in Woodbridge, June 12, 1785.

Oct 26, 1785: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):
TO BE SOLD AT PUBLIC AUCTION, at the Sign-Post in Milford on Monday the 12th day of December next, at nine o’clock in the forenoon: So much of the real estate of …, Thaddeus Nettleton, Nathan Nettleton, Abel Northrup, …,And at the Sign-Post in Woodbridge, on Tuesday, the 13th day of December next, at eleven o’clock in the forenoon; So much of the real estate of …, Hannah Chatfield, Sarah Chatfield, Joel Chatfield, …, as will pay their State taxes, due to me on the list 1781, with the charges arising thereon.

NEWTON PRUDDEN, Collector.

Milford, October 11, 1785.

Note: presumably, Hannah Chatfield (who is 57 and widowed) is the mother of Joel (age 28)

Sep 4, 1793: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 3):
TAKEN up a few days since, a large BAY HORSE, trots and canters, no mark or brand. The owner is desired to take him away and pay charges.JOEL CHATFIELD.

Derby, Sept. 2, 1793.

Note: Joel Chatfield is age 36

Sep 14, 1796: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):

TWO-PENCE REWARD.

Runaway from the subscriber living in Derby, and indented servant boy named Josiah Coger, about nineteen years of age. All persons are forbid harboring him on the penalty of the law. The above reward, (but no charges) will be paid, on returning him to JOEL CHATFIELD.

Derby, August 26, 1796.

Note: Joel Chatfield is age 39

Dec 1, 1806: The Connecticut Journal, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 1):
Broke into the Enclosure of the Subscriber, about the 4th of October last, a black two year Steer.—Strayed from the subscriber the summer past, a red white fac’d Bull, one year old past. The owner of the Steer is requested to pay charges and take him away.—A generous reward will be given for information of the Bull.JOEL CHATFIELD.

Derby, Dec. 1, 1806.

Jan 1, 1810: Connecticut Herald, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):
List of Letters
Remaining in the Post-Office, New-HavenJanuary 1, 1810.

…, Joel Chatfield, …

☞Where the name of the town is omitted, the direction is for New-Haven. All Letters not called for in three months, will be sent to the General Post-Office. Any person having advertised Letters, will please mention it when they call for them.

JESSE ATWATER, P.M.

New-Haven Post-Office, Jan. 1, 1810.

America Declares War on Britain
The War of 1812 was fought between the United States of America, on one side, and Great Britain, the British North American colonies, Upper and Lower Canada, and Nova Scotia on the other. The war was fought from 1812 to 1815 and involved both land and naval engagements. The Americans declared war on Britain on June 18, 1812, for a combination of reasons—outrage at the impressment (seizure) of thousands of American sailors into the British navy, frustration at British restraints on neutral trade while Britain warred with France, and anger at British military support for hostile Indians blocking American settlement of the Old Northwest, which by treaty with Britain belonged to the U.S.The war had the effects of both uniting together Canadians and also uniting together Americans far more closely than either population had been prior to the war. Canadians remember the war as a victory by avoiding conquest by the Americans, while the Americans celebrated victory in a “second war for independence”.
Source: Wikipedia online

1812: Joel Chatfield, Sr. is 55 years of age when he serves his country in the War of 1812, as a Private in Capt. David Beacher’s Company, Col. Edward Russell’s Regiment, Connecticut Troops. A very complete record of Joel’s descendants is given in Seymour Past and Present (pgs 419-422), by Rev. Hollis A. Campbell, William C. Sharpe, Frank G. Bassett; W.C. Sharpe Publisher, 1902.

Apr 8, 1815: Columbian Register, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):
List of Letters,Remaining in the Post-Office New-Haven,

April 1, 1815.

***Persons calling for these letters are requested to mention that they are advertised.
Woodbridge—…, Isaac Chatfield, …,

All letters not called for within 3 months will be sent to the General Post Offices.

WM. H. JONES, P.M.

Jun 18, 1870: Federal Census for Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut.
Wheeler, Almira: age 78, female, Keeping House. Value of Real Estate $2,000, born Connecticut, father foreign born, mother foreign bornTirza Chatfield: age 72, female, Keeping House, Value of Personal Property $1,600, born Connecticut

Rimden, Ellen: age 28, female, Domestic Servant, born Ireland, cannot read, cannot write

Note: Almira (Chatfield) Wheeler is the widow of John Todd Wheel, living with her sister Thirza Chatfield